mydiresearch, ~discoveries & further ~developments
Grijze lucht met regendruppels & het geluid van de wind. Terug en vooruit dus maar weer met Yeshayahu Leibowitz, Uri Davis & Danny Boyarin:
ends & means, faith & language, visions & practices of people then & there, here & now through all ages, places, cultures & human development.
Y makes a sharp distinction, drawn by Maimonides & reflecting Aristotelian influence, between ends-in-themselves & secondary ends, which are ends for us only because they subserve some further end. The original context of this distinction was a teleological concept of nature according to which things had their natural ends. As used by L, without any reference to such a context, the distinct is rather similar to the familiar classification of values as intrinsic & instrumental. Yet there is a difference. Though there is no natural hierarchy of ends, some ends, once recognized, must be take as ultimate. They are incapable of being validated by reference to further ends. But YL goes further: he adopts two crucial doctrines of Maimonides on this matter: first, the religious end is not only an end-in-itself but is THE ultimate end; second, an ultimate end is desecrated when it is made to serve as a means to some other end.
What is the religious end? For YL it is worshipful service of G d, or halakhic praxis. It could not affect G d, & bears no comparison with ordinary human values. The religious practitioner will divorce his religious action from any hope for reward of fear of punishment other than the status before G d achieved in living the life of Halakhah. This is a religious content , not a sociological one. One need not deny the functionality of religious practices for social solidarity or their role in preserving the national identity of Jews. But these are empirical questions that are religiously irrelevant. To attempt to justify adherence to Mitzvoth by its consequences, whether for society, nation, or individual, is to take up a secular point of view which does not recognize the primacy & ultimacy of the worshipful service of G d. Religiously, this is an inversion of the scale of values.
Beetje ingewikkeld? Je kunt al die namen & begrippen natuurlijk ook gewoon opgoogelen & er zelf mee aan 't goochelen gaan zoals "christenen" e.d. over 't algemeen al doen voor bijna alweer meer dan tweeduizend jaar met alle gevolgen vandien all over this 'complicated world'!
Asih, man, 81 jaar
Log in om een reactie te plaatsen.
-
O
02 sep 2023
45173193 Je ziet ‘n forse man met donker haar dat
-
O
02 sep 2023
4517225192 De Beul Van Ommen: Om De Dossiers In Te
-
O
02 sep 2023
45171151De tèkst stamt uit de late middeleeuwen...
-
O
02 sep 2023
45170150MóederDrama:Ewa,Miryam,Mia,Els,Ria,Saartje
-
O
02 sep 2023
45169149’t Gegéven van ‘t Láátste Óórdeel is naast
-
O
01 sep 2023
45168148 Víer jaar eerder componeerde Antonio
-
O
01 sep 2023
45 167 147 Alle andere personages in de passies,
-
O
01 sep 2023
45166146’n Link van Liturgisch Spel naar OratorIum
-
O
01 sep 2023
45165-145In de Filmwereld kwam Pier Paolo Pasolini
-
O
31 aug 2023
45163145 De kèrn van ‘n tekstboek voor een muziek-
-
O
31 aug 2023
45161144 De persoon YÈSJ werd in ‘n muzikaal drama
-
O
30 aug 2023
45160 Partij Van De GroenLinkse ArbeidStrijdVlag?
-
O
30 aug 2023
45159pvdgla: Bulderend, dreigend, huilend, zalvend
-
O
30 aug 2023
45158 De titel zou een vingerwijzing blijken naar
-
O
30 aug 2023
45157143PS’Intensiteit Van Hartstocht Ìs Zó Hévig,
vorige
volgende