jbml thln 86b I found compelling, some years ago
THE PHRASE
"evolution lost."
It invoked in my mind both "this view of life" as something precious that we no longer have or at least have placed at moral risk, and, insofar as extinction and thus an end to the evolution of our species seemed much more plausible, the notion of a contest in which the very process of evolution itself had failed. The latter as least was a fallacy, for as Peter J. Richerson & Robert Boyd lucently point out in their book
NOT BY GENES ALONE,
that a cultural pattern may be maladeptive (leading toward ex-tinction rather than species success) hardly means it is not a product of evolution.
In evolutionary terms, the phrase I was looking for (though much less evocative) was doubtless something more like "adaptation lost."
When we say "adaptive," we refer to that which fosters the likelihood of reproduction. Moreover, while we know that extinction is part of evolution, we tend to usually associate evolutionary success with a progression from past to future (hence the mild astonishment of a younger anthropologist colleague at my assertion that I take an evolutionary but not a progressive perspective). We cannot reproduce ourselves in the past ~ or can we?
If you are right that "the past represents the events we can possibly have observed and recorded in memory," then it is certainly true at least that our capacities to observe and record can grow and in THAT sense at least the past expands toward the future.
As Richerson and Boyd predict,
"[m]ore surprises in both past and future climates are virtually a certainty."
"evolution lost."
It invoked in my mind both "this view of life" as something precious that we no longer have or at least have placed at moral risk, and, insofar as extinction and thus an end to the evolution of our species seemed much more plausible, the notion of a contest in which the very process of evolution itself had failed. The latter as least was a fallacy, for as Peter J. Richerson & Robert Boyd lucently point out in their book
NOT BY GENES ALONE,
that a cultural pattern may be maladeptive (leading toward ex-tinction rather than species success) hardly means it is not a product of evolution.
In evolutionary terms, the phrase I was looking for (though much less evocative) was doubtless something more like "adaptation lost."
When we say "adaptive," we refer to that which fosters the likelihood of reproduction. Moreover, while we know that extinction is part of evolution, we tend to usually associate evolutionary success with a progression from past to future (hence the mild astonishment of a younger anthropologist colleague at my assertion that I take an evolutionary but not a progressive perspective). We cannot reproduce ourselves in the past ~ or can we?
If you are right that "the past represents the events we can possibly have observed and recorded in memory," then it is certainly true at least that our capacities to observe and record can grow and in THAT sense at least the past expands toward the future.
As Richerson and Boyd predict,
"[m]ore surprises in both past and future climates are virtually a certainty."
14 mrt 2013 - bewerkt op 17 mrt 2013
- meld ongepast verhaal
Log in om een reactie te plaatsen.
- O 01 jan 2026 50336102/9: Mensen zoon dochter kind vriend taal?
- O 01 jan 2026 50335 De Slaven die naar deze Wijngaard gestuurd
- O 01 jan 2026 50334101Dit is ‘t brandpunt v/d botsing van Yesjoe
- O 31 dec 2025 50333100 Zelfs E. Meyer beschouwt dit visioen als
- O 31 dec 2025 50332 YESJ nam Sjim’on “Petra”, Yochanan & Ya’akov
- O 31 dec 2025 5033199 DOOR mij heb jij ‘t gezicht van Velen ver-
- O 31 dec 2025 50330 Pas sinds de ontdekking van de geschriften
- O 31 dec 2025 50329/98 Als YESJ als een Zoon was voor God, dan
- O 30 dec 2025 50328/97 Die charismatische vrome mannen geloofden
- O 30 dec 2025 50327/96 ÉÉN DING is echter zeker ook nú híer nòg
- O 30 dec 2025 50326 We zien dus duidelijk dat er ook al in deze
- O 30 dec 2025 50325 Dat is duidelijk ver bezijden de waarheid:
- O 30 dec 2025 50324 ‘t Meest typisch aan zoogdierlijke mensen is
- O 29 dec 2025 5032395 Choni kwam om ‘t leven tijdens die burger-
- O 29 dec 2025 5032294’t Is geen toeval dat de hemelse stem sprak